Her Lie, Presence

The page was close to tearing. Veyn had gone over the same corner three times without meaning to, and the ink had pooled there. He stopped. Set the pen down. Looked at the corner and couldn’t say when he had done it.

Outside the window, everything that wasn’t this building was ruins. An office block, maybe, or something that had been a hospital. It leaned against the orange sky, its upper floors open to weather that had been getting in for years. Snow sat in the gaps. Nothing moved.

He looked at it until it stopped meaning anything.

The corridor was unusually noisy. Most of the time, other members in the hall won’t come out of their room, until they gathered for dinner.

Veyn heard them, snapping him off his thoughts. He turned to the door. His number was on his door. 9.

But still he didn’t move. His legs had been bad for some days, the bruising deep enough that sitting down was the only position that didn’t cost him something. He stayed in his chair, and just gazed outside.

“Veyn Kmerst.”

It took him by surprise. His name was followed by arguments by familiar voices, with the person who called out his name.

Two boys in blue stood in the corridor. The taller one had a girl hanging from his sleeve, both hands knotted in the cuff, her heels skidding on the floor. He didn’t seem to feel the weight. A few steps off, the second boy was bent toward someone younger, who held an empty mug against his chest and did not give up an inch of ground.

“What,” Veyn said.

Everything stopped. The boys looked at him, then at each other, the way people did when they had expected someone else. Someone larger. Someone harder to drag out of a room.

“Are you Cold Wind?” the taller one asked.

The hall went quiet. The name reached him and his hand was already moving. He shoved the door shut, and a boot caught the frame before the latch did. Then a hand came through the gap and closed on his wrist.

“You’re coming to the main office.” The grip tightened until the bones in Veyn’s wrist shifted against each other. “We have questions regarding the murder of Tiuhar Reese.”

“No!” The girl hauled on the sleeve with her whole body. It cost the boy nothing. “I told you. You’ve got the wrong person.”

“Look at him,” the younger boy said. He lifted his chin. “As if someone shut in like that could be him.”

Veyn pulled. The hand did not give. He set his feet and pulled again, and the bruises answered, a deep pain that took the strength out of his knees before he could use it. He let go of the door and caught the frame instead.

“Show us the order,” the younger boy said. “On paper. Signed.”

“Questions don’t need paper.”

“Then you don’t need him.”

“He can barely stand,” the girl said. Her voice had dropped. “Look at his legs.”

“Then he’ll sit in the office.”

The second boy in blue had been giving ground, a step back for every step Archie took forward. Now he stopped. “That’s enough from you,” he said, and then, to all of them, “Any more, and I will bring the whole of Clock Hall to the student council.”

The girl opened her mouth.

“Stop.”

The voice came from the end of the corridor, flat and mechanical, without a trace of breath.

Tember sat in his chair, head against the rest, hands lying motionless in his lap. A screen on an arm hung before his face, its light pale against his jaw. His eyes moved across it, and the speaker at the chair's arm gave voice to his selection.

Behind him, the others had come out of their rooms. They stayed where they were.

Nobody spoke while he worked. The cursor moved across the grid of letters, pausing here and there. The boys in blue waited with the rest of the hall. The grip on Veyn’s wrist did not loosen, but the boy holding it stood very still.

“Riliie. Archie.” A pause. “Step back.”

The girl didn’t move. Then her fingers came off the cuff one at a time. The younger boy took a single step backward, mug pressed to his chest, jaw set.

Tember's eyes left the screen and found Veyn.

“Please comply. I believe it is for what you did a week ago.”

Veyn looked at him. Tember looked back.

The breath left Veyn through his nose, long and slow. The tension went out of his arm, and the boy at his wrist, who had braced for more, shifted his feet. Veyn took his hand off the frame and stood on his own legs. It hurt. He let it, and walked.

No one came forward. Not to take his arm, and not to take the other boy’s. They watched Veyn pass every door, until the boys in blue took him through the double doors at the end.

The doors had not finished swinging when the girl’s voice came through the gap.

“You know they’re trying to pin it on him!”

The answer came without delay, flat and even, carrying down the empty hall.

“I know. But I also know that Veyn can overcome this easily.”

The taller boy’s grip didn’t change. Ahead of them, the stairs began, and the first one cost Veyn more than the whole hall had.

⁂

"I don't know."

He said it the way he had said it the previous three times. The boy across the table exhaled and leaned back. Then he stood, came around the table and crouched until his face was level with Veyn's. A hand closed around Veyn's wrist.

"Don't make this harder than it needs to be." He almost managed a smile.

Veyn looked at him. "Or else."

"Or else—"

The door opened. The one who came in was tall and formally dressed, and he moved like rooms were already his. Veyn's eyes went to him.

He looked at the boy crouching beside Veyn, then at Veyn.

"Or else what?" he said.

He didn't raise his voice. The boy at Veyn's side let go and stood, giving up the place without being told. The newcomer crouched where he had been.

"Last Tuesday was a warning," he said, low. "This is a murder case." He let that sit. "So you understand the difference."

The print of fingers was already darkening on Veyn's wrist. His legs ached as they had for days. None of that had changed.

"I understand it," Veyn said. "Do you, Aare?"

The room went quiet.

Nobody here said that name to him. They said sir. They said pres. It showed in his face. He was nineteen. Veyn was fifteen, and he held the older boy's eyes as if the four years were nothing.

Aare took Veyn's face in one hand. Not a slap. Fingers pressed into the jaw.

"I went easy on you," he said. "Understand that. I went easy." He held the grip a moment longer. "This is a murder case. I will have you exiled. Out there." The room had no window, and he did not gesture at one. "Do you understand what that means."

He let go. The push that followed was not hard. The chair tipped anyway, and Veyn had nothing in his legs to catch it. One shoulder hit the floor.

Aare straightened his jacket. He looked at the other boy.

"Make sure he speaks, Trin."

"Yes. Yes, I will."

Aare left. The door clicked shut behind him.

Trin stood where he was. Then he walked over to where Veyn lay and kicked him in the stomach.

The air left Veyn. The sound that came out was small, and he heard it.

"Confess," Trin said. "Please. Confess."

"Why are you so desperate," Veyn said from the floor, between breaths.

"What?"

Veyn pushed himself onto one elbow. His stomach would bruise. "You came here in a hurry."

"I don't know what you're—"

"You're student council." Veyn looked at him. "But half your shirt isn't tucked in. And you don't have your glasses."

Trin went still.

"How do you know I wear glasses?"

"You held the sheet almost to your nose. People do that when the print blurs."

Silence.

Then Trin pulled his chair around and sat on it backwards, arms folded over the back, looking at Veyn with something that wasn't quite a smile.

"I get it now," he said. "Why they call you that."

Veyn didn't say anything.

"Top of every exam. Knows everything about everything. Stays invisible to everyone." He leaned forward. "And now here you are."

"I'm not Cold Wind."

"Sure." He nodded slowly. "Sure, you're not."

The light above them hummed.

"Is there even any evidence," Veyn said.

"Oh, there's evidence."

"What kind."

"Someone saw you. That night."

Veyn looked at him. "That's an eyewitness."

"Yes."

"That's not proof."

Trin's expression didn't change. "It's enough."

"It isn't." Veyn shifted his back against the leg of the table. "Before the collapse there were courts. Proper ones. Eyewitness testimony was considered among the weakest thing they had."

Trin said nothing.

"A person can believe what they saw and still be wrong. Darkness. Distance." He pressed a hand flat to his stomach and waited for the breath to come back. "They see a shape and fill in the rest themselves."

Trin was quiet. "Interesting," he said. "So where were you? Ten to midnight, two nights ago."

"My room. Reading."

"Alone."

"Yes."

"No alibi."

"No."

Silence again, longer.

"Nobody from Clock Hall saw you?" Trin's voice had dropped. "You don't meet up, not even once?"

"We do. But." Veyn looked at his legs, bruises. "I was shut in my room."

Trin sighed. "You know what that means."

Veyn didn't answer.

Trin stood, crossed to the door and stopped with his hand on the frame.

"You're finished," he said without turning. "I'll make sure of it." His hand stayed where it was. "Until then, stay here."

The door closed. Veyn stayed on the floor until the footsteps were gone.

⁂

The room had two chairs, one table and four walls. Veyn touched each wall in turn. He wasn't looking for a way out, and he found none.

Two nights ago. He righted the fallen chair, sat, and closed his eyes to retrace it. Halfway through he pressed two fingers to his temple and kept them there until it eased.

He took a sheet from the pile of documents, turned the printed side down and found a pencil.

He wrote what he knew about Tiuhar Reese.

Popular. Athletic. Same classroom as Veyn, a different climate entirely. Tiuhar took up rooms: laughed too loud, kept three girls within arm's reach. He borrowed answers before exams and passed by margins that never seemed to trouble him. He had never once asked what Veyn scored.

Veyn's hand stopped.

Then it moved again, and at the bottom of the page he wrote: *Someone is framing me.*

He wrote names beneath it. Everyone he could place near Tiuhar in the last week. The list was short, and he knew it. Past it he had nothing: no murder weapon, no place of death, no timeline beyond what Trin had given him, which was almost nothing.

"Like the murder weapon and place of death?"

He turned.

A girl was leaning in the doorway, arms folded, head tilted, watching him with mild interest. Pale. Silver bangs covered the left side of her face entirely. Her visible eye was bright.

"Oh, don't mind me," she said, though he hadn't said anything. She pushed off the frame and walked in as if she'd been invited, glancing around the room as though it had let her down. "They really put you in this one. Charming."

He looked at the open door.

"Sielsia Serebryakova." She dropped into the other chair. "Head of Mist Tree. We're a club. Very exclusive, very mysterious. The name's a pun." She took the pencil from beside his hand, looked at it and set it down. "Did you kill him?"

"No."

"Okay, cool." She spun the pencil once. "Then we need to fix this."

She leaned over and read his notes sideways, hair falling across her face. "Body was in the bushes in front of the main building classrooms, by the way. Whoever did it was sloppy. Like, embarrassingly sloppy."

"What else do you know."

"Mmm." She straightened. "Trin will give you the rest without meaning to. He's not very good at this."

"What do you mean, the rest. How much do you know."

"Enough." She grinned. "Enough to know it wasn't you, anyway. The kill was sloppy. You're not sloppy." A pause. "Kind of a compliment, really."

"Then help me."

"Nope."

He stared at her.

"I could." She turned the pencil end over end. "I've done it before. Solved things, helped people, very noble, whatever. But you?" She pointed it at him. "You can do this yourself. I know you well enough."

"We've never met."

She opened her mouth—

"SIELSIA."

Trin stood in the doorway. Glasses on now, shirt tucked in. His face was doing several things at once. His eyes went to Sielsia, to Veyn, to the open door, back to Sielsia.

Veyn noticed him. Then he noticed who stood at Trin's elbow, a girl who came up only to his shoulder, and his eyes widened. Maya.

"How are you in here," Trin said.

Sielsia turned in her chair and waved at him as if he were very far away. "My friend's in council? Ring any bells?"

Trin crossed the room toward her. Maya stayed where she was, hands at her sides, eyes on Veyn. Sielsia turned back to him, and for a second the grin was something quieter.

"Solve this," she said. "And I'll tell you something you've been looking for your whole life."

Trin took her arm and she went with it, feet dragging, her free hand waving at Veyn over her shoulder. Maya stepped out of the doorway to let them pass. The door shut behind them.

Maya crossed to the end of the table. Veyn was looking at the door. He went on looking at it after the latch had caught. She did not clear her throat or say his name. She stood with her hands folded and waited, and when it became clear he would not look at her, she kept waiting.

The door opened. Trin came in alone, breathing hard through his nose, and shut it behind him.

"So," he said. "What did she say?"

"Nothing," Veyn said. "She said nothing."

Maya's eyes stayed on him. She had been standing at the door when Sielsia spoke. She said nothing either.

Trin held Veyn's gaze, then looked down at the sheet in his hand. He took it and read it at a normal distance this time. Then he crumpled it, the printed side and Veyn's writing together, and dropped it on the floor.

"Your theories?" he said. "None of them matter." He pointed at Maya. "She came here to testify against you."

"I am here to state what I know," Maya said.

She did not look at the finger aimed at her, or at the paper on the floor. She said it to Veyn, not to Trin.

"And that would be enough." Trin sat at the table. Maya stood across from him, at Veyn's side. Veyn's chair was against the wall. "Tell me what happened that night."

"Nine at night. I came out of my room for dinner." She paused. "Everyone did, except Veyn."

Veyn exhaled.

"Unue went to check on him. He didn't open the door, so she left the food she'd made outside it and joined us. We ate, and we stayed until midnight."

"Why until midnight?"

"We gather every night. Tember suggested it."

"And in all that time, no one checked on Veyn?"

"At the end, Unue and Tember knocked. He didn't respond."

"I was asleep," Veyn said.

"Good excuse."

Veyn said nothing.

"So now we have it from a witness that you have no alibi."

"That's not proof—"

"It's enough!" Trin slammed the table. Neither Veyn nor Maya flinched. "This is not the old world, and nobody here cares what its courts needed. For the student council, it's enough."

Veyn looked at Trin, then at Maya. Then he let his head fall back against the wall and looked up at the light.

"This is stupid," he said under his breath.

Maya touched her thumb to each fingertip in turn, counting something. "Unue assumed Veyn was still hurt and could not come out. That is why she left him the food."

"An assumption isn't a fact," Trin said.

"Facts are." She did not look up from her hand. "Veyn was injured then and is injured now. It is impossible for him to have killed someone."

Nothing in her voice was for him.

Veyn did not react. He had already found the same gap in it.

Trin leaned back. "He could still have killed him."

Veyn's eyes came down from the light and found Trin. "How? I can barely stand. Did I stab him in the back?"

"Yes."

Trin reached under the table. His hand came back holding a knife, and he was already moving, one arm over the table at Maya.

“Wait—” Veyn caught her sleeve and pulled. His legs answered for it.

The blade went into the tabletop and stayed there.

It had never been going to reach her. It took Veyn a moment to understand that. He let go. Maya had not so much as stepped back. She straightened her sleeve where his hand had been.

“Oh, don’t worry,” Trin said, amused at their faces. “It has already claimed its life.”

He pointed at the knife. “This is the murder weapon.”

Veyn knew the handle.

“Twelve grade toppers get Clock Hall,” Trin said. “So its rooms are the most lavish in the academy. Your own restroom. A kitchen. Cutlery sets that belong to no one else.” He worked the knife out of the table and turned it in the light. “This knife is unique to Clock Hall.”

His smile faded. “I tried to finish this without giving away a single clue. I really did.” He looked at them both. “But I understand why the council hates Clock Hall, and now that I have the chance, I won’t stop at breaking it a little.”

Neither of them answered the threat.

“The body was found in the bushes in front of the main building.” He set the knife down on the table. Veyn saw where he was going. “Clock Hall is on the ground floor, a short walk from the site. At that hour the grounds were dark. He could have called Tiuhar out beforehand. Waited until he turned his back. One stab from behind, and almost nothing to resist it.”

His smile came back. “So, you see. He could have done it, injuries and all.”

Maya blinked once. Trin looked back at Veyn, who was staring at the handle and did not seem to hear.

“The student council is forever grateful for your contribution, Maya.” He stood and opened the door. “Please. Get out.”

Maya went out without a glance back. Veyn was still looking at the knife.

“Did she come on her own,” Veyn said. He looked straight at Trin. “Or did you make her?”

“I didn’t have to.” Trin shrugged. “The moment I went for her, Tember told her to follow me.”

Veyn paused. “He didn’t want this to go any further.”

Trin leaned against the table. “Cute, isn’t it? Even the grade toppers have to follow us.”

“I suppose.” Veyn said it low. “He trusted me with everything, after all.”

He let the silence run. “You went straight for Maya. Why her?”

“Because Maya is the only one who won’t lie,” Trin said at once. “She can’t be biased.”

“You really know about us.” Veyn leaned forward.

“The council keeps every one of you in check. It’s common knowledge.”

Veyn paused, then a short laugh left him. “Cute,” he said. “Even the council has to follow us.”

Trin’s smile went.

“Keep smiling, Kmerst.” His voice had dropped. “I want to remember that face when they put you out there.”

“Exile.” Veyn pushed himself up out of the chair and crossed to the table, one hand on the wall for the first steps. “The whole premise is stupid.” He stopped across from Trin. “Do you think I’m stupid?”

“What?”

“Do you think Cold Wind is stupid?”

Trin didn’t answer.

“If I killed someone.” Veyn stopped. “If Cold Wind killed someone, why leave the knife? Why not dispose of it properly?” He let it sit. “You’re telling me the person who has terrorized this entire academy for months forgot the most basic thing.”

Trin’s jaw tightened. “Fine,” he said after a moment. “Maybe you’re not Cold Wind.” He pulled out the chair and sat down, slowly, thinking as he did it. “But that doesn’t clear you of this. Maybe it was your first kill. Maybe you panicked. Maybe you made mistakes you wouldn’t make again.”

“Convenient,” Veyn said. “What could even be my motive? I don’t know him.”

“We don’t need one.” Trin’s voice was flat. “Confess.”

The word came out tired, almost. “Say it, and this gets easier for everyone.”

“I won’t confess to something I didn’t do.”

Trin stood. He didn’t rush. He pushed back the chair and walked around the table at the same deliberate pace, as if he had all the time he wanted. Veyn followed him with his eyes and nothing else.

Then Trin’s forearm was across his throat, walking him backward. His legs gave him two steps before the wall met his shoulders. Not violent, exactly. Controlled. Enough to make breathing require attention.

Veyn kept his hands at his sides. Nothing he could do with them would help.

“Confess or don’t,” Trin said, close now. “It doesn’t matter as much as you think. I’ll find the truth either way.” A pause. “And when I do.”

He let it hang there, unfinished. Then he stepped back.

Veyn’s breath came back in stages. He stayed against the wall a moment longer, then pushed off it with both hands.

Trin smoothed his jacket. He looked around the room as if checking that he had forgotten nothing.

“You’re staying here.” He went to the door, opened it and said something to whoever stood in the corridor, too low to catch. Then he walked out without looking back.

The door stayed open.

A boy appeared in the doorway a moment later. Younger than Trin by two years at least, slight, standing with the careful posture of someone who had been corrected about it often enough that it had become habit. He looked at Veyn, then at the room, then at Veyn again.

“I’m Snirt,” he said. “I’ve been asked to—”

“I know,” Veyn said.

Snirt nodded. He locked the door and came in and took a position near the wall, standing, hands at his sides.

Veyn looked at the table, bare now, then at the ceiling. He pulled out the chair, considered it, and sat on the edge of the table instead. Then he lay back along it, one leg at a time, arms folded over his chest, staring up at the light.

Snirt watched him.

Time passed. The light hummed.

“Why are you staring at me,” Veyn said to the ceiling.

“I was told to keep an eye on you.”

“So you’re like Trin.”

Snirt shifted his weight. “What do you mean.”

“Strict about your duties.”

“Oh.” A pause. “Not really. I mean, Trin is dedicated, yeah. He worked hard to get where he is. He follows orders. I’m not like that.”

“Being dedicated to your work isn’t a bad thing.”

“No,” Snirt said. “It’s not. Until it starts showing up on other people.” A pause. “Like it did when he had a girlfriend.”

Veyn turned his head on the table. “Had.”

“It’s... nothing. Forget I said—”

“They broke up.”

“I wish it were that simple.”

Veyn waited.

Snirt looked at the door. “She cheated on him.”

“Oh.”

A long pause.

“But that’s not why it wasn’t simple. He found out the same day she killed herself.”

The light hummed.

“Dvoly,” Snirt said. “You might know the name. A few months ago. The student council did the preliminary work. Mist Tree ruled it a suicide.” He stopped.

“There should have been a note,” Veyn said.

“Yes. Only the higher-ups were allowed to see it.” He sighed. “They decided among themselves it wasn’t important. Suicide, so no culprit.”

Neither of them spoke.

“No culprit,” Veyn said, still looking at the ceiling.

Snirt didn’t answer.

“Can a person be responsible for someone’s death without having killed them?”

Snirt frowned. “You mean by hurting them.”

“Perhaps.”

“People hurt each other all the time. Mostly they don’t know they’re doing it.”

Veyn looked at his wrists. The skin was still raised where Trin had held him, and the marks were beginning to colour.

“Does not knowing make it smaller?”

“No. But you can’t ask people to know where the line is. It’s different for everyone. Something that’s nothing to one person is—” Snirt stopped. “How would you know?”

“You might not.” Veyn turned his head toward him. “But forgetting only works on the one who did it.”

Snirt looked at him. His mouth opened and closed.

The light hummed.

“After you know,” Veyn said to the ceiling, “it’s yours.”

Neither of them spoke.

“Then do you feel responsible,” Snirt said. “For killing him.”

“I didn’t kill Tiuhar.”

Snirt looked at him. Dark circles under the eyes, the pupils wide in the dim room. Steady. Whatever was behind them did not move.

“Even if you didn’t,” Snirt said, “the evidence holds against you.”

Veyn looked at the ceiling again. Snirt looked at the wall. The door was shut now. Veyn had not heard it close.

“Where did Trin go?” Veyn said, eventually.

“Searching your room. For more evidence.”

Veyn’s head came off the table. He sat up in one motion, and the bruise in his stomach did not slow him. “What do you mean.”

“What, scared he’ll find something?”

He was off the table and at the door before Snirt finished. The handle didn’t move. He tried it again, both hands this time, his whole weight behind it, which wasn’t much.

“I have the key,” Snirt said, coming off the wall. “You can’t—”

Veyn struck the door with the flat of his hand. Then again. The sound was small.

“Hey—” Snirt took a step toward him.

“Open it.” Veyn didn’t turn. “Snirt. Open it.”

“I can’t. Trin said—”

“I know what Trin said.” His forehead had come to rest against the wood. “I can’t let them see it.”

His voice had changed. The flatness was gone.

“I can’t... please.”

The last word came out small, almost without his meaning it, and the wood took it in.

Snirt’s hand stayed in his pocket.

The handle turned from the other side.

Veyn stepped back. The door opened and Trin came in holding a sheet of paper. He looked at Veyn. Then at the door. Then at Veyn again.

He said nothing. He held the sheet and waited.

“What did you find in my room.” Veyn’s voice was level again.

Trin glanced down at the sheet. Something in his face settled into satisfaction. “You asked for a motive.” He turned the sheet so Veyn could see. “Transaction records. Tiuhar’s account. Why is it in your room?”

Veyn looked at the sheet.

The breath that left him was slow, almost quiet. His hands hung at his sides. Something in his jaw that had been set for an hour let go.

“Sorry,” Veyn said. “What did you say.”

Trin’s expression flickered. “Are you deaf? Or completely defeated?” He stepped closer, holding the sheet out. “Transaction records. Tiuhar’s account. Found in your room.”

“How did you get into my room.”

“The council gets a warrant when it has reasonable cause. You know how this works. Like last time, when we came in and you were...” He let the pause stand. “Dealt with.”

“I remember that day,” Veyn said. He touched the bruising along his arm without looking down. “I don’t remember you specifically.” “I was there.”

“Behind Aare.” Veyn looked at him. “That’s where you usually stand, isn’t it.”

Something in Trin tightened. When he spoke, the official tone was gone.

“So smug,” he said. “Even now.” He moved closer. “But look at me. Aare gave me something real. The killer in this case. You.” He stopped in front of Veyn. “I won’t disappoint him.”

Snirt hadn’t moved from the wall. He watched them.

Trin picked the sheet up from the table. “Tiuhar used to cheat in exams.”

Veyn said nothing.

“You fed him answers. His scores climbed. Yours stayed perfect. Nobody looked twice, because a boy like you wouldn’t stoop to it.” He held the sheet between them. “He paid you. That’s what this is.”

“It’s a withdrawal,” Veyn said. “So where’s the cash?”

Trin’s mouth opened.

“You turned my room over and found the paper. You didn’t find what it paid out.”

“You hid it.”

“Then someone careful enough to hide the money kept the one page that points at me.” Veyn held his eyes. “Pick one.”

Trin said nothing. The sheet in his hand had begun to bend at the edge.

He set it down and straightened. What was in his face now had nothing to do with the case.

“You know what I think,” he said. “I think you talk your way out of everything. I think you’ve done it your whole life.” He came closer, close enough that Veyn could see the tiredness under the anger. “Not this time.”

His hand came up.

Snirt moved off the wall. Stopped. Trin’s eyes cut to him without his head turning.

“Stand there,” Trin said.

Snirt stood there.

Trin turned back. His hand was still raised. His breathing was the loudest sound in the room.

The door opened.

Sielsia leaned against the frame, arms folded, taking in the room with the air of someone who had arrived slightly after the best part.

“Oh good,” she said. “I didn’t miss it.”

Trin turned. “How are you—”

“My friend. Council.” She waved it away and walked in, unhurried, glancing at the sheet on the table, at Snirt by the wall, at Trin’s hand, which he lowered a second too late. She looked at Veyn last. “Very dramatic in here.”

“Leave,” Trin said. “Mist Tree has nothing to do with this.”

“Mm. I said I wouldn’t help him, right? I meant that.” She picked up the sheet, looked at it, set it back down. “But I’ve solved a lot of cases here. A lot. And I’d hate for this one to close wrong.” She gave Trin a smile that was entirely pleasant and entirely unreadable. “Let Mist Tree prove it’s him. Properly. Give us the chance, and if we can’t, he’s yours.”

Trin sighed. He thought it over for a long moment. “Ten minutes. That’s all you get.”

Sielsia clapped her hands once. “Okie dokie.”

She took Veyn by the wrist, the marked one, and pulled him around to the other side of the table, positioning him like a prop in a show she had already rehearsed. Trin and Snirt became the audience by default. Snirt seemed to accept this. Trin did not.

“So.” Sielsia spread her hands. “Everyone present. Today, Mist Tree does its magic again.”

Snirt clapped once, the way people do at magic shows before they remember where they are. Trin’s eyes moved to him. Snirt’s hands separated and found his pockets.

“Today’s mystery,” Sielsia went on, “is the death of Tiuhar Reese.” She gestured at the room, at the sheet, at Trin. “As you’d have guessed.”

Veyn closed his eyes for a moment.

“Now. I am, as many know, a strong advocate of giving new members a chance.” She turned to him with the face of someone about to do him a tremendous favor. “The newest member of Mist Tree—”

“I’m not a—”

“Veyn Kmerst,” Sielsia said over him, “will be uncovering the mystery today.”

“Me?”

“Him?” Trin said, at the same moment. “But you said you would prove it.”

“I said Mist Tree would. That still holds.” She smiled at him pleasantly.

Veyn looked at her. “I don’t know anything.”

“You do.” She bent to his height and drew his head toward her, close enough that only he could hear. “Deduction begins where intuition is established. Say what your heart believes, then let your mind prove it.”

She straightened.

“I choose my members with the greatest care,” she said. “Prove me right.”

Veyn looked at her. Then at Trin, already crossing the room toward her.

“Stop with the drama—”

“Our newest member is nervous.” Sielsia produced a water bottle from somewhere and held it out to Veyn.

He took it. He drank slowly. Fine bubbles rose from the bottom at first, then settled as the bottle emptied.

He set it on the table.

“Trin.”

Trin stopped.

“I realized something.”

“That you murdered Tiuhar.”

“That Dvoly had an affair with Tiuhar.”

The room went flat.

Trin didn’t move. The color left his face and came back unevenly.

“Tiuhar talked about girls,” Veyn said. “How easily he pulled them. The kind of thing you hear and forget.” He let it sit. “It stops being forgettable when one of them is yours.”

“You.” Trin’s voice came out low, almost unrecognizable. “You pulled my dead girlfriend into this. How heartless. What proof do you even have—”

“None. Of the affair.”

“Ha—”

“I don’t need it. I don’t have to prove they were together to prove you killed him.”

Sielsia leaned against the table with her arms folded. She was watching Veyn’s face, not Trin’s.

“You came into that room in a hurry,” Veyn said. “Shirt out. No glasses. A man who got news and moved before he thought.” His voice stayed level. “You weren’t investigating this case, Trin. You were managing it.”

Trin said nothing.

“Where was Tiuhar found.”

“Bushes. In front of the main building.” Trin’s voice had gone mechanical, somewhere between fury and something that hadn’t decided what it was yet. “You know that.”

“I know what I was told. A body in the bushes, and everyone calls it sloppy. But he doesn’t have to have been killed on the ground.”

“WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT.” Trin slammed the table. The empty bottle rocked and settled. Veyn did not flinch.

“Call a boy up to a room to talk,” Veyn said. “Make a noise outside. He goes to the window to look. One stab from behind while he leans out, and the blood goes down with him.” He took a step. “You told me this yourself. Called out beforehand. Back turned. Almost nothing to resist it. You described it perfectly for me.”

Trin’s jaw worked.

“Where were you? Ten to midnight, two nights ago.” Veyn waited.

Trin didn’t answer.

“It’s all right.” Veyn stepped back. Snirt was looking at the floor.

“Everyone called it sloppy,” Veyn said. “Careless. The work of someone who panicked. What if it wasn’t? What if it was the one kill that never had to leave the room? You didn’t need the corridor. You didn’t need to carry anything. You needed a window and a reason.”

“Stop—”

“You had both.”

“I said stop—”

“And you needed someone to blame.” Veyn took his hand off the table and stood on his own legs. They hurt. He stood anyway. “A week ago you came into my room behind Aare. I know that handle. I eat with the rest of the set. You took it, and you knew nobody in Clock Hall could say it wasn’t mine.”

“You knew where I’d be. The council keeps every one of us in check, you said. You knew Clock Hall sits together until midnight, and that I’d be in my room because I couldn’t walk to dinner.” He let that stand. “You were there when that happened.”

“And when you needed a witness, you chose the one who can’t lie. Maya won’t, you said. You didn’t need her to lie. You needed her to say, truthfully, that nobody saw me.”

Trin had gone gray.

“The transaction record. Tiuhar’s money, I’d guess, for the girls he was seeing. You searched my room alone today. You didn’t find that sheet. You brought it.” Another step. “And the eyewitness. The weakest evidence there is. Someone you know, I’d guess. Someone who would say what you needed.”

He was close now. Trin had to look down at him.

“You took my knife,” Veyn said. “You called him to your room. And you killed him.” A pause. “You killed him for her.”

Trin’s hands shook at his sides. His face had nothing left to arrange.

“And when it was done, you looked for someone who couldn’t fight it,” Veyn said. His voice did not rise. “Out of everyone in this academy, you chose me.” A pause. “Keep that face, Trin. I want to remember it when they put you out there.”

Then Trin laughed.

It came out too high, too fast.

“Ha. Hahahaha.” He stepped back. “Good theory. Great theory. You have nothing. Nothing that proves—” His voice cracked and kept going. “YES. Yes, I killed him. I killed him, and you will NEVER—”

“Play’s over.”

The voice came from behind Trin.

Slow, deliberate clapping. Three claps. Then silence.

Trin turned.

Aare stood in the doorway, hands dropping back to his sides, looking at Trin the way you look at a thing you expected to break.

“Aa... Aare?”

“You call me by name too now,” Aare said. “Interesting.” The word carried nothing.

“Sorry, I mean, pres, I—”

“It doesn’t matter.” Aare stepped into the room. Two more in blue came in behind him and moved to either side of Trin without being told. “I made the correct decision, giving you this case.”

Trin’s face went somewhere desperate. “Pres—”

“I knew you killed Tiuhar.” Aare looked at him without cruelty, and that was worse. “I wanted to see what you’d do with it. How far you’d go.” He glanced at Veyn. “Farther than I expected, apparently.”

The two in blue took Trin by the arms.

“WAIT—” Trin pulled against them, not hard enough, the fight already leaving him. “You don’t understand. Tiuhar deserved it. He deserved it after what he did to Dvoly, after what he made her—” His voice broke. “The girl I love—”

Tears ran down his face. He didn’t seem to notice.

“She killed herself because of him. I did this for her.”

“No,” Veyn said. “You didn’t do it for her.”

Everyone in the room looked at Veyn.

Trin’s face was wet. His arms were held. He was looking at Veyn as if waiting for something to stop, and nothing was stopping.

“You were climbing,” Veyn said. “Every order followed, every rank earned, everything pointed up toward Aare. That’s where you were looking.” He paused. “Dvoly was beside you, and you were looking up.”

Trin didn’t speak.

Veyn looked at his wrist, at the marks the grip had left. “Today you put a forearm to my throat over a confession you didn’t need. You raised your hand in front of witnesses. A boy you’d known for an hour.” He lifted his eyes. “Snirt told me your dedication shows up on other people. What were you like with her?”

Snirt looked at the floor.

“So she was alone,” Veyn said. His voice stayed flat. Not cruel. Precise. “With someone who was supposed to be there and wasn’t. And then someone else was. Someone who noticed her. Someone like Tiuhar, who made a habit of noticing girls.”

Trin’s jaw tightened.

“She didn’t leave you for him. She was already gone before that. She was filling the space you left.” Veyn looked at him. “But she was afraid of you. Of what the council meant. So she said nothing, and stayed.”

The room was still.

“And when Tiuhar moved on, because he always moved on, she had nowhere left. She couldn’t go back to you. She couldn’t go forward. She was already tired.”

He stopped.

The silence held.

“So tell me,” Veyn said. “Revenge? Jealousy? A power trip, because he had something that was yours?” He looked at Trin. “Think carefully. Who really killed her. Tiuhar—”

He let the word sit there, unfinished, in place of the other name.

“YOU—”

Trin tore free. The two holding him had stopped expecting a fight, and they weren’t ready for it. His fist reached Veyn’s face before anyone moved, and Veyn’s head snapped to the side. The second punch came, and blood came with it, running from his nose over his mouth.

“HOW DARE YOU.” Trin’s voice had broken open. “HOW WOULD A LONER LIKE YOU KNOW WHAT IT FEELS LIKE TO LOSE SOMEONE—”

His arms were taken again. He pulled against them, couldn’t move, and kept pulling.

Veyn straightened slowly. His nose was still bleeding. His legs hurt as they had all day. He looked at Trin, and his mouth pulled sideways, red at the edges.

“Even a loner like me,” he said, “realized this.”

The fight went out of Trin all at once. At the door his knees gave, and the two in blue took his weight between them. They walked him out.

The door closed.

Aare looked over the room. His eyes settled on Sielsia.

“Your habit of prying into our affairs will be your downfall,” he said.

“Let’s see.” Sielsia smiled at him. “Which lasts longer, my curiosity or this student council.”

“Yes.” Aare’s mouth curved slightly. “Let’s see.”

He looked at Veyn. “We don’t hate Clock Hall,” he said. “We take the measures that serve the academy.”

He left.

Snirt came to where Veyn was still standing and steadied him by the arm, careful where he put his hands.

“Thanks,” Veyn said. “For the information.”

“I never thought it would go like this.” Snirt looked at him. “Go to your room. Rest. You look terrible.”

“I would.” Veyn looked at Sielsia. “But someone made a promise.”

Sielsia was already at the door. “Follow me.”

⁂

Maya knocked on Tember’s door. She waited, then knocked again, the same number of times at the same spacing.

Doors opened along the corridor. Unue came first, drying her hands on a cloth. Riliie followed, then the rest in ones and twos, until the hall held everyone who usually stayed behind their doors until dinner. Archie stood at the back with his arms crossed and did not pretend he had come out for anything else. Cerm’s door opened a hand’s width and stayed there.

Tember’s door opened last. He sat in his chair with the screen’s light pale along his jaw and said nothing. He was waiting for her to begin.

“Is it Veyn?” Unue asked.

“Yes.”

“They haven’t released him.”

“Not when I left.”

“We should have stopped them at the door,” Riliie said. “All of us.”

“We did what Tember told us to do,” Unue said. She did not look at him.

Riliie looked at the floor and didn’t argue.

His cheek moved. The speaker took it. “Go on, Maya.”

“Sielsia Serebryakova was in the interrogation room before I gave my statement.” Maya’s thumb touched each fingertip in turn. “She spoke with Veyn. When Trin arrived, he removed her.”

Nobody moved.

“What did she want with him?” Tember asked.

“She told him that if he solved the case, she would tell him something he has been looking for his whole life.”

The screen’s light on Tember’s jaw did not change. The silence held a while.

“And Veyn?”

“He looked at the door for some time after she left. Then Trin asked him what she had said, and Veyn told him she had said nothing.”

“And you?”

“I said nothing either.” Her hand stopped. “I was not asked.”

“She said solve.”

Nobody heard it the first time. Riliie turned, then the rest, and Cerm drew his hands further into his sleeves. He stood half in his frame, eyes on a point near Maya’s shoes.

“She said solve,” he said again, a little louder. “Not ‘if you’re cleared.’ Not ‘if they let you go.’” His voice thinned and kept going, as if stopping would cost more. “She wants him working. She already thinks he can do it. Nobody says that about someone they haven’t been watching.” He swallowed. “Mist Tree already has a council member in it. Now she’s reaching for one of us.”

“Why Veyn?” Unue said.

“I don’t know.” He looked down the hall at the closed double doors. “But Sielsia answers to neither Clock Hall nor the council. If Veyn goes to her, Mist Tree stops being something we can ignore.”

No one disagreed. Tember waited.

Cerm lifted his eyes, the first time he had looked at anyone, and found the back of the hall.

“Archie.”

⁂

The corridor was longer than he remembered. Veyn’s steps came unevenly, the good leg and the bad one negotiating each stretch separately. Dried blood pulled at his upper lip when he spoke. Sielsia walked ahead with her hands in her pockets, unhurried, her silver hair catching the light at each lamp.

Students stepped aside for her and looked at him.

“Where are we going?”

“How do you feel about joining Mist Tree?” She didn’t turn.

“I said I wouldn’t.”

“It wasn’t a request.” She glanced back. “It’s a trade. You solved your case, and you want what I promised. You can’t get it from anyone else. The person you were before the collapse.”

Veyn stopped.

⁂

Snirt stood in the corridor outside the interrogation room, still holding the key ring as if he had forgotten what it was for.

Archie came down the hall at a run and went past him without slowing.

“You can’t go in there—”

“Where is Veyn?”

“He left. With Sielsia.” Snirt pointed. “That way.”

Archie didn’t go. He had stopped inside the doorway.

A water bottle stood alone in the middle of the bare table. It was empty, but a ring of fine bubbles still clung to the bottom and would not settle.

⁂

Students moved past Veyn on both sides. He put a hand out toward the wall, and the wall was somewhere else.

The edges of his vision blurred. He blinked and looked at his hands. They were further away than they should have been.

“Catch Cold Wind,” Sielsia said, ahead of him, her voice arriving a half-second late, “and I’ll tell you about...”

She said a name.

“Lili.”

He heard it come back out of him, a whisper. His own voice, saying something his memory had no record of.

⁂

Archie picked up the bottle and smelled it. Coffee had taught him every kind of bitter. This was not one of them. Under the water was something sharp and chemical, wrong.

“This is poison.”

He wasn’t speaking to Snirt. He was already running.

⁂

The floor came up. He didn’t feel himself fall, only the cold of the tiles and hands that weren’t Sielsia’s, and a voice very far away shouting for someone to look at him. He reached. His arm moved wrong, too slow, as if it belonged to someone else.

Silver hair was the last thing he could make out, somewhere in the crowd, getting smaller.

No. Please.

His fingers closed on nothing.

Lili. I don’t know her.

A tear ran from the corner of his eye into his hair. He felt that clearly. Everything else was going.

Then why...

“Lili,” he whispered.

⁂

Archie pushed through the crowd until he reached him, dropped to his knees and took Veyn’s face in both hands. “Veyn. Veyn!”

He was small, and no one came forward to help him. He kept at it anyway.

⁂

In Clock Hall nobody had gone back to their rooms. Cerm stood at the end of the corridor with one hand on a doorframe, looking at the double doors Veyn had been taken through.

On his chair, Tember’s cheek moved, and the speaker took it.

“Why do I feel,” Tember said, “like we have already lost him.”

Nobody answered. The cursor on his screen stopped moving.

⁂